"Reform Movement" redirects here. For specific organizations by that name, see Reform Movement (disambiguation).
Not to be confused with Reformation.
A reform movement is a type of social movement that aims to make gradual change, or change in certain aspects of society, rather than rapid or fundamental changes. A reform movement is distinguished from more radical social movements such as revolutionary movements.
Reformists' ideas are often grounded in liberalism, although they may be rooted in socialist (specifically, social democratic) or religious concepts. Some rely on personal transformation; others rely on small collectives, such as Mahatma Gandhi's spinning wheel and the self-sustaining village economy, as a mode of social change. Reactionary movements, which can arise against any of these, attempt to put things back the way they were before any successes the new reform movement(s) enjoyed, or to prevent any such successes.
Main article: Radicalism (historical)
The Radical movement campaigned for electoral reform, a reform of the Poor Laws, free trade, educational reform, postal reform, prison reform, and public sanitation. Originally this movement sought to replace the exclusive political power of the aristocracy with a more democratic system empowering urban areas and the middle and working classes. Following the Enlightenment's ideas, the Reformers looked to the Scientific Revolution and industrial progress to solve the social problems which arose with the Industrial Revolution. Newton's natural philosophy combined a mathematics of axiomatic proof with the mechanics of physical observation, yielding a coherent system of verifiable predictions and replacing a previous reliance on revelation and inspired truth. Applied to public life, this approach yielded several successful campaigns for changes in social policy. Eventually, in 1859, this reform movement led to the formation of the Liberal Party. Soon, the landed gentry, prosperous business men, and high-ranking officials created the Conservative Party to counter the rising strength of liberalism in Parliament.
The greatest success of the Reformers was the Reform Act 1832, which provided the rising middle classes with more political power in urban areas, while lessening the representation of areas of England undisturbed by the Industrial Revolution. Despite determined resistance from the House of Lords to the Bill, this Act gave more parliamentary power to the liberals, while reducing the political force of the working class, leaving them detached from the main body of middle class support on which they had relied. Having achieved the Reform Act of 1832, the Radical alliance was broken until the Liberal-Labour alliance of the Edwardian period.
The Chartist movement
Main article: Chartism
The Chartist movement sought universal suffrage. A historian of the Chartist movement observed that "The Chartist movement was essentially an economic movement with a purely political programme." A period of bad trade and high food prices set in, and the drastic restrictions on Poor Law relief were a source of acute distress. The London Working Men's Association, under the guidance of Francis Place, found itself in the midst of a great unrest. In the northern textile districts the Chartists, led by Feargus O'Connor, a follower of Daniel O'Connell, denounced the inadequate Poor Laws. This was basically a hunger revolt, springing from unemployment and despair. In Birmingham, the older Birmingham Political Union sprang to life under the leadership of Thomas Attwood. The Chartist movement demanded basic economic reforms, higher wages and better conditions of work, and a repeal of the obnoxious Poor Law Act.
The idea of universal male suffrage, an initial goal of the Chartist movement, was to include all males as voters regardless of their social standing. This later evolved into a campaign for universal suffrage. This movement sought to redraw the parliamentary districts within Great Britain and create a salary system for elected officials so workers could afford to represent their constituents without a burden on their families.
The women's rights movement
Main article: Women's suffrage
Many consider Mary Wollstonecraft's Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792) to be the source of the reformers' long-running campaign for feminist inclusion and the origin of the Women's Suffrage movement. Harriet Taylor was a significant influence on John Stuart Mill's work and ideas, reinforcing Mill's advocacy of women's rights. Her essay, "Enfranchisement of Women," appeared in the Westminster Review in 1851 in response to a speech by Lucy Stone given at the first National Women's Rights Convention in Worcester, Massachusetts in 1850, and it was reprinted in the United States. Mill cites Taylor's influence in his final revision of On Liberty, (1859) which was published shortly after her death, and she appears to be obliquely referenced in Mill's The Subjection of Women.
A militant campaign to include women in the electorate originated in Victorian times. Emmeline Pankhurst's husband, Richard Pankhurst, was a supporter of the women's suffrage movement, and had been the author of the Married Women's Property Acts of 1870 and 1882. In 1889, Pankhurst founded the unsuccessful Women's Franchise League, but in October 1903 she founded the better-known Women's Social and Political Union (Suffragettes), an organization famous for its militancy. Led by Pankhurst and her daughters, Christabel and Sylvia, the campaign culminated in 1918, when the British Parliament the Representation of the People Act 1918 granting the vote to women over the age of 30 who were householders, the wives of householders, occupiers of property with an annual rent of £5, and graduates of British universities. There was also the Warner's suffrage movement, which also involved women's suffrage.
Reform in Parliament
Earl Grey, Lord Melbourne and Robert Peel were leaders of Parliament during the earlier years of the British reform movement. Grey and Melbourne were of the Whig party, and their governments saw parliamentary reform, the abolition of slavery throughout the British Empire, and Poor Law reform. Peel was a Conservative, whose Ministry took an important step in the direction of tariff reform with the abolition of the Corn Laws.
William Ewart Gladstone was a reformer. Among the reforms he helped Parliament pass was a system of public education in the Elementary Education Act 1870. In 1872, he saw the institution of a secret ballot to prevent voter coercion, trickery and bribery. By 1885 Gladstone had readjusted the parliamentary district lines by making each district equal in population, preventing one MP from having greater influence than another.
United States: 1840s–1930s
- Religion the Evangelical pietistic Protestant churches were active in numerous reforms in the mid-19th century, including temperance and the abolition of slavery. See Second Great Awakening
- Art – The Hudson River School defined a distinctive American style of art, depicting romantic landscapes via the Transcendentalist perspective on nature.
- Literature – founding of the Transcendentalist movement, which supported numerous reforms.
- Utopian Experiments.
- New Harmony, Indiana (founder: Robert Owen) – practiced economic communism, although it proved to be socially flawed and thus unable to sustain itself.
- Oneida Commune (founder: John Noyes), practiced eugenics, complex marriage, and communal living. The commune was supported through the manufacture of silverware, and the corporation still exists today, producing spoons and forks for households of the world. The commune sold its assets when Noyes was jailed on numerous charges.
- Shakers – (founder: Mother Ann Lee) Stressed living and worship through dance, supported themselves through manufacture of furniture. The furniture is still popular today.
- Brook Farm (founder: George Ripley), an agriculture-based commune that also ran schools.
- Educational reform – (founder: Horace Mann); goals were a more relevant curriculum and more accessible education. Noah Webster's dictionary standardized English spelling and language; William McGuffey's hugely successful children's books taught reading in incremental stages.
- Women's rights movement – Founded by Lucretia Mott and Elizabeth Cady Stanton who organized the Seneca Falls Convention in 1848 and published a Declaration of Sentiments calling for the social and legal equality of women. Carried forward by Lucy Stone who began speaking out for women's rights in 1847, and organized a series of national conventions. Susan B. Anthony joined the cause in 1851 and worked ceaselessly for women's suffrage.
- American labor movement – The campaign against excessive hours of work (and for the eight-hour day) was a central issue for the labor movement during the 19th century. The Knights of Labor, organized among the skilled trades in 1869 and led by Uriah Stephens, Terence Powderly and Mother Jones, was succeeded by the American Federation of Labor, the Congress of Industrial Organizations (combined now as the AFL-CIO), and the Industrial Workers of the World.
- Child labor reform – Lewis Hine used his camera as a tool for social reform. His photographs were instrumental in changing child labor laws in the United States.
- Abolition movement – The addition of Mexico's former territories in 1848 at the conclusion of the Mexican-American War reopened the possibility of the expansion of race-based chattelslavery; the adaptation of the slave system to industrial-style cotton production resulted in increasing dehumanization of black workers and a backlash against slavery in the northern states; key figures included William Lloyd Garrison and Frederick Douglass.
- Know-Nothing movement, also anti-Catholic, anti-Masonic, and nativist (1845–1856)
- Prohibition or Temperance movement – Characterized by Frances Willard'sWoman's Christian Temperance Union, which stressed education (formed 1881, declined in 1940s) and Carrie Nation's Anti-Saloon League (established nationally by Howard Hyde Russell), which promoted a confrontational approach towards bars and saloons. Other significant organizations include the Prohibition Party and Lincoln-Lee Legion.
Mexico: La Reforma, 1850s
Main article: La Reforma
The Mexican Liberal party, led by Benito Juárez and Sebastián Lerdo de Tejada, guided the emergence of Mexico, as a nation state, from colonialism. It envisioned a modern civil society and capitalist economy. All citizens were equal before the law, and Mexico's 1829 abolition of slavery was reaffirmed. The Liberal program, documented in the 1857 Constitution of Mexico, was based on:
- Abolition of the fueros which had granted civil immunity to members of the church and military
- Liquidation of traditional ejido communal land holdings and distribution of freehold titles to the peasantry (the Ley Lerdo)
- Expropriation and sale of concentrated church property holdings (beyond the clergy's religious needs)
- Curtailment of exorbitant fees by the church for administering the sacraments
- Abolition of separate military and religious courts (the Ley Juárez)
- Freedom of religion and guarantees of many civil and political liberties
- Secular public education
- Civil registry for births, marriages and deaths
- Elimination of all forms of cruel and unusual punishment, including the death penalty
- Elimination of debtor's prisons and all forms of personal servitude
Ottoman Empire: 1840s–1870s
Main article: Tanzimat
The Tanzimat, meaning reorganization of the Ottoman Empire, was a period of reformation that began in 1839 and ended with the First Constitutional Era in 1876. The Tanzimat reform era was characterized by various attempts to modernize the Ottoman Empire, to secure its territorial integrity against nationalist movements and aggressive powers. The reforms encouraged Ottomanism among the diverse ethnic groups of the Empire, attempting to stem the tide of nationalist movements within the Ottoman Empire. The reforms attempted to integrate non-Muslims and non-Turks more thoroughly into Ottoman society by enhancing their civil liberties and granting them equality throughout the Empire. Peasants often opposed the reforms becauyse they upset traditional relationships.
Republic of Turkey: 1920s–1930s
Main article: Atatürk's Reforms
Atatürk's Reforms were a series of significant political, legal, cultural, social and economic changes that were implemented under the leadership of Mustafa Kemal Atatürk in the early years of the Republic of Turkey. Between the years 1905 and 1918 Mustafa Kemal was deservedly awarded high-ranking posts in the military chain of command. He became Chief of General Staff of the army that was sent out from Saloniki to put down the uprising of the 13 April 1909, a movement designed to return the country to Hamadic Absolutism and which had started with the non recognition of the Constitution that had been declared on 23 July 1908. Mustafa Kemal proved to have special qualities in the organisation and management of this army of oppression, known as the Army of the Movement. In 1910 he led the Turkish forces during military manoeuvres in the Province of Picardy in France. In 1911 he fought in Tripoli against the Italians, and in 1914 whilst serving as Military Attaché in Sofia, he successfully drew the government's attention to the catastrophic results connected with Turkey's entry into the war with Germany and its allies.
During World War I Mustafa Kemal fought against the Allied Forces at the Dardanelles, the Russians on the Muş Front, in the east and against the British in Syria and Iraq. During the war he visited Germany as military adviser, together with hereditary Prince Vahdettin. At the time of signing the Armistice Declaration on 30 October 1918 Mustafa Kemal remained at the head of his troops, a command given to him by the German General Liman von Sanders. In the years between 1919 and 1923 Mustafa Kemal was at the forefront of the Turkish War of Independence and involved with the eradication of the antiquated institutions of the Osmanic Empire and in laying the foundations of the new Turkish State. He approached the National Congresses of Erzurum and Sivas to organise and lift the morale of the people in its determined opposition to the Forces of the Entente who were occupying Anatolia.
By the end of these conventions he had managed to convey the message that the idea and the ideals of outdated imperialism ought be dropped so that people within the national boundaries could make decisions in accordance with the principles and general guidelines of an effective national policy. After the occupation of Istanbul by the Forces of the Entente he laid the foundations for the new Turkish State when in 1920 he united the Great National Assembly in Ankara. With the government of the Great National Assembly, of which he was President, Mustafa Kemal fought the Forces of the Entente and the Sultan's army which had remained there in collaboration with the occupying forces. Finally, on 9 September 1922 he succeeded in driving the Allied Forces back to Izmir, along with the other forces which had managed to penetrate the heartland of Anatolia. By this action he saved the country from invasion by foreign forces.
Monument, Newcastle upon Tyne
as Palmerston's Chancellor of the Exchequer
- ^Elie Halévy, The Growth of Philosophic Radicalism. Faber (1972) ISBN 0-571-04759-9
- ^G. M. Trevelyan, Lord Grey of the Reform Bill: Being the Life of Charles, Second Earl Grey (London: Longmans, Green, 1913)
- ^G. D. H. Cole, Short History of the British Working Class Movement, 1787-1947. London, George Allen & Unwin (1948), pp. 63-69. "The Reform Movement"
- ^G.D.H. Cole, Short History of the British Working Class Movement, 1787-1947. London, George Allen & Unwin (1948), p. 94 "The Rise of Chartism"
- ^John Stuart Mill, The Subjection of Women, The Feminism and Women's Studies site (e-text)
- ^Daniel Walker Howe, What Hath God Wrought: The Transformation of America, 1815–1848 (2007).
- ^William G. McLoughlin, Revivals, Awakenings, and Reform: An Essay on Religion and Social Change in America, 1607–1977 (1978).
- ^Menikoff, Aaron (2014). Politics and Piety: Baptist Social Reform in America, 1770-1860. Wipf and Stock Publishers.
- ^E. Attıla Aytekın, "Peasant protest in the late Ottoman Empire: Moral economy, revolt, and the Tanzimat reforms." International Review of Social History 57.2 (2012): 191-227.
Presentation on theme: "Liberal Reforms A Success?"— Presentation transcript:
1 Liberal Reforms A Success?
2 Example Essay Questions
To what extent did the Liberal Reforms improve the lives of the British people?Assess the impact of the Liberal Reforms on the lives of the British people.
3 Theme of EssayThe Liberal Reforms were at best piecemeal – covered a wide range of poverty and were limited in who they helped.However, they were the widest range of reforms by any government at that time and show a change of emphasis away from laissez-faire and towards governments looking after the welfare of their people – it is this change in attitude by which their success must be judged, they began welfare reform.Therefore, key points:1. Very limited reforms.2. But first time widespread welfare reforms were regarded as people’s rights.
4 Content of Essay In your essay you must show:
1. An understanding of the problems Britain faced.2. What the Liberals did – details of legislation passed.3. Strengths and limitations of reforms.
5 5 Big Problems facing Britain 1906
Britain faced many problems caused by poverty at the beginning of the 20th Century, for example:Squalor – Each major town and city e.g. Glasgow, East End London had very poor and overcrowded housing that were filled with disease.Disease – Major epidemics of TB, Scarlet Fever, Polio, Rickets etc swept through the slums, most were caused by poverty.
6 5 Big Problems facing Britain 1906
Want – Poverty was a major problem caused by a society where the working class faced low pay, long hours and lived on the margins( the poverty line) with no room for sickness, death, unemployment etc.Idleness - One of the main causes of poverty were caused by the lack of regular well paid work. Most jobs were seasonal or subject to periods of unemployment, as well as illness etc. If you did not work your family did not eat.
7 5 Big Problems facing Britain 1906
Ignorance – There was compulsory education up to 13 but most schools were crowded and of poor quality. Education for girls was much worse than boysPlease note – little or nothing was done by the Liberal Government to help the problems of squalor, disease and ignorance.
8 Reforms We will study the Liberal Reforms under three headings:
1. Young2. Old3. Workers
9 YOUNG - Children 1906 Education Act (School Meals)
Provided meals for needy children.Compulsory education had shown up the evils of poverty, as children from the slums were too hungry to learn.
10 Good pointsBy 1914, 14 million school meals were being issued per week.This ensured that needy pupils were receiving one nutritious meal per day.Helped to tackle the evil of ‘WANT’, by helping needy children.Helped (slightly) to tackle the problem of ‘IGNORANCE’, as allowed children to learn without the distraction of hunger.
11 Bad points School meals were not made compulsory until 1914.
Pupils only receiving a nutritious meal on school days.
12 YOUNG - Children 1907 Education Act (Medical Inspections)
Medical inspections started at school, school nurses checked for lice, TB, rickets etc.After 1912, education authorities could also provide free medical treatment.
13 Good pointsHelped to identify if pupils had illnesses like TB and rickets.Advice (not treatment) given to parents (although few could act on advice as had no money!).Did establish how widespread diseases caused by poverty were.Therefore, helped to tackle the evil of ‘DISEASE’.
14 Bad points Did little to cure disease.
Education authorities largely ignored the 1907 Act providing for free medical treatment.
15 OLD - Elderly 1908 Old Age Pensions Act Pensions for those 70 years +
Between 1 to 5 shillings per week (5p to 25p)Could be collected at the post office.
16 Good pointsThis was the first time that the government had taken care of the elderly population.This help was given as a right rather than as charity.Therefore, helped to tackle the evil of ‘WANT’.
17 Bad pointsPension age was too high, e.g. life expectancy for working class men in 1900 was 51 (pension at 70)Payment was small – ¼ of average wage.Lots of people were excluded, e.g. for immorality such as being a drunkard, having been in prison etc.
18 WORKERS – Sick and Unemployed
1911 National Insurance Act (Part 1)Introduced compulsory health insurance for workers in certain trades earning less than £160 per year.The slogan was ‘9d for 4d’ – the employee paid 4d, the employer 3d and the state 2d to provide sickness benefit of 9d.
19 1911 National Insurance Act (Part 2)
Compulsory scheme of unemployment insurance for trades badly hit by periodic unemployment e.g. ship building, construction.The worker, employer and the state made weekly contributions – if the worker fell out of work, he got 7 shillings a week(35p) in benefit for up to 15 weeks in any year.
20 WORKERS - smaller ActsIntroduced Labour Exchanges like modern day job centres to let unemployed find jobs- 400 established.1908 Miners 8 hour day – limited time men were forced to work underground1909 Trades Board act supposedly to protect sweat shop workers by fixing minimum wagesShops Act 1911 limited working hours in shops, guaranteed shop worker a ½ day off per week.
21 Good pointsState recognising responsibility to workers – not always the workers fault if they were ‘idle’.Therefore, helping to tackle the evil ‘WANT’.Shops Act, Labour exchanges showed growing move away from Laissez-faire and government responsibilities to workers.
22 Bad pointsHealth insurance only provided for the employee and not his family. Was only 7 shillings for 15 weeks, covered only 7 trades.Unemployment insurance only applied to 7 trades e.g. shipbuilding, construction and not others e.g. farming.
23 Summary – were the reforms successful?
YoungElderlyWorkersAct Good points Bad points Successful?
24 How effective were the Liberal Reforms?
The Liberal Reforms were piecemeal and limited at best and did not solve any of Britain’s social problems at that time.The majority of the reforms were of limited value.Many areas were ignored – there was little done to improve health or education and nothing at all to improve housing.Poor Law and workhouses remained.
25 Some have made exaggerated claims that the Liberal Reforms were the beginnings of the welfare state.
But the reforms were never intended to solve all of Britain’s problems or to set up a complete welfare system.
26 There were however many good points:
It was the first big example of a change in attitude by government away from the strict dogma of laissez-faire.Some help given to the poorest in society – eg. School children.For the first time the rights of certain sections of society to protection was recognised – eg. Elderly.It began the process of welfare reform and took it out of the domain of charitable works.