Whenever you read an essay, use the following questions to guide your response.
First, keep in mind that, although you may not be a writing expert, you are THE reader of this essay and your response is a valid one. I have found that almost every reader, regardless of experience, can identify the primary strength and weakness in an essay, although their method of describing those issues may be different. The author will welcome your response and your ability to explain your reaction in a new way. Although the author is not required to, and really shouldn’t, respond to everything you say, he or she will take your comments seriously and consider how the essays has enlightened or confused you. Therefore, comment freely, although respectfully. Keep in mind that it is better to begin by noting the strengths of the essay before pointing out the areas that need improvement. I would always include a personal response to questions like the following: What about the essay most connects with your experience? Moves you? Provokes you? Entertains you?
So that is how to respond. So how do you critique? For every essay, regardless of the mode, consider the broad categories of content, organization, style, and correctness.
- Content: Consider the topic (its appropriateness and interest for the assignment as well as a clear focus suitable to essay length) and the way the topic is developed (clarity sufficiency of its argument, its scope, subcategories, amount and type of examples, anecdotes, evidence, etc.).
- Organization: Consider how the essay is introduced and concluded (especially looking for a “frame” to the essay, where the intro and conclusion refer to the same idea), whether the thesis is located in the most helpful place (direct or implied), how the essay is structured, whether the order or extent of development is successful, as well as how individual paragraphs are organized (clear topic sentences, appropriate and concrete evidence, logical organization of evidence).
- Style: Style can refer to the overall style of an essay: whether the tone is appropriate (humorous, serious, reflective, satirical, etc.), whether you use sufficient and appropriate variety (factual, analytical, evaluative, reflective), whether you use sufficient creativity. Style can also refer to the style of individual sentences: whether you use a variety of sentences styles and lengths, whether sentences are worded clearly, and whether word choice is interesting and appropriate.
- Correctness: Correctness refers to grammar, punctuation, and form of the essay. You do not need to know the exact grammatical term or rule to know when a sentence is not correct. Even though you may not know the term dangling modifier, you could identify that the following sentence is not correct:
Rolling around in the bottom of the drawer, Tim found the missing earring. [certainly the earring was rolling, not Tim!]
You could also easily tell that the following sentence actually contains two sentences that need punctuation between them:
The new manager instituted several new procedures some were impractical. [You need to add punctuation (period) after “procedures” and capitalize “some.”]
Feel free to mark the essay at the point of the error with a specific recommendation (“run-on sentence”) or a general comment (“this sentence sounds wrong to me”). You can also simply put an “X” by any sentence that seems incorrect. See the back of WR for commonly used Correction Symbols.
Further Directions for Specific Assignments
Below are more detailed questions to consider when responding to individual types of essays. First, make sure that you have reviewed the description of the essay mode in the Essay Assignment Guidelines. Use at least one or two of these when responding to an essay. Do not simply answer yes or no; offer specific evidence from the text and elaborate on the reasons behind your answer.
Personal Essay Critique:
- Does the writer have a clear but understated purpose to the essay?
- Does it avoid being overly moralistic or heavy-handed?
- Does the essay contain suspense or tension that is resolved in some way?
- Do you have any suggestions for organizing the essay, such as focusing in on one event rather than many, providing more background, turning explanation into action, etc.?
- Does the essay make good use of concrete description, anecdote, and dialogue?
- Does the essay help you to feel the emotions rather than just describe the emotions of the author?
- Does the essay reveal a significant aspect of the writer’s personality?
- Does the writer seem authentic?
- Is this a passionate piece? Is it creative?
Critical Review Critique
- Does a direct thesis convey both the subject and the reviewer’s value judgment?
- Does the review provide a summary or description to help you experience the film, music, event, etc.? Note places where the author provides too much or too little detail.
- Does the essay clearly identify relevant criteria for evaluation? Are they appropriate, believable, and consistent?
- Are any important features of the reviewed subject omitted?
- Logos (logic, content): Does the essay provide sufficient, relevant, and interesting details and examples to adequately inform and entertain?
- Ethos (author): Does the author’s judgment seem sound and convincing?
- Pathos (emotional appeals): Does the author responsibly and effectively utilize emotional appeals to the audience?
- Does the author include adequate reference to the opposition and respond to that opposition appropriately?
Information Essay Critique: The questions posed about an informative essay will vary, depending on the purpose and strategy of the essay. The SMGW suggests evaluating for the following issues:
- Is topic clearly explained and sufficiently focused?
- Does the content fit the audience?
- Is it organized effectively?
- Are definitions clear?
- Are other strategies (classification, comparison/contrast, analysis) used effectively?
- Are sources used sufficiently, effectively, and appropriately?
You might also assess the following criteria:
- Does the author utilize vivid detail, interesting examples, and lively language?
- Does the essay avoid emphasizing judgment over explanation?
- Does the essay have a clear focus or implied thesis?
Comparison/Contrast Essay Critique
- Is the purpose for a comparison or contrast evident and convincing?
- Does the essay identify significant and parallel characteristics for comparison?
- Does the author adequately explain, analyze, or reflect on the comparison or contrast?
- Does the author provide appropriate transitions words to indicate comparison and contrast?
- Is the treatment of each side of the comparison or contrast in balance?
- Does the essay provide sufficient, relevant, and interesting details?
Feature Article Critique
- Does this article interest you? Do you think it will interest the intended audience? Can you suggest ways to increase interest?
- Can you tell what the “angle” or implied thesis is? Does the author avoid editorial judgment on the subject while still keeping the purpose clear?
- Has the writer done sufficient research? What questions have gone unasked or unanswered? Whose point of view or what information would add further to the completeness of the feature?
- Is the subject presented vividly with sensory images, graphic detail, and figurative language? Do you have suggestions of details or images to include?
- Does the writer use an appropriate mixture of anecdote, quotation, description, and explanation? Would more or less of one of these improve the essay?
- Are the beginning and ending paragraphs interesting and appropriate for the specific audience? Consider the need for a “lead sentence” if intended for a newspaper.
Documented Argument Critique
- Is the thesis clear, argumentative, and effective? Why or why not?
- Are the topic and thesis are reasonable for the assignment, audience, and context of the essay?
- Does the author define his or her terms and provide sufficient background information? What ideas or terms are undefined or inadequately explained?
- Is the thesis supported by clear reasons? Are the reasons clearly worded and supported sufficiently?
- Do the reasons fit logically together and are they placed in the right order?
- Does the author adequately address the opposition? What is another opposing argument he/she should or could have addressed?
- Has the author done adequate research?
- Are the works cited adequately introduced and explained before citing from them?
- Does the paper contain an appropriate blend of well-placed quotations within a context of the author’s own words and paraphrases from other sources?
- Is the writer clearly in charge, naturally introducing and interacting with sources rather than merely reporting on them?
- Do you find the argument convincing? What might you add or omit?
Business Writing Critique
- Does the memo begin with the most important information?
- Does the memo build rapport by involving the reader in opening paragraph?
- Does the memo provide sufficient, relevant, and interesting details? Is it focused and brief?
- Does the memo focus each paragraph on one idea?
- Is the memo informed, accurate, demonstrating the author’s grasp of the situation?
- Is the final paragraph calling for a specific action? Is it brief? Does it build good will?
- Is the memo form correct, with concise subject line, initialed name, correct spacing?
- Is the information arranged (indentations and numbering) in a way that makes it easy to skim and still get central information?
- Does the first paragraph identify who the author is, briefly state why he/she is writing, and refer to how he/she found out about the job?
- Does the second paragraph highlight specific strengths, special abilities, or features of the résumé to be noted?
- Does the third paragraph make a specific request of the reader or address what action is to be taken?
- Does the letter provide sufficient, relevant, and interesting details to make the request convincing?
- Is the letter brief and focused? What elements could be eliminated?
- Does the writer achieve his or her purpose? Does it make you want to consider the résumé more carefully?
- Is the tone of the letter courteous without being too formal, relaxed without being too familiar?
- Is the letter’s form appropriate (heading, spacing, greeting, salutation)? Is the letter addressed to a specific person rather than a general “Dear Madam/Sir”?
- Does the résumé contain the necessary features for the position (name/address, position desired, education, work experience, achievements, relevant personal information, references)?
- Does the résumé contain only essential, relevant information for the position required?
- Does the résumé emphasize the applicant’s strengths?
- Does the résumé emphasize what is unique about this person’s experience? Does it demonstrate a common interest or ability (leadership, teaching experience, dedication, creativity, etc.)?
- What additional information might you like to have about this applicant?
- If you were leading an interview based on this résumé, what are two questions you might ask?
- Does the résumé look neat (appropriate spacing, clear headings, good quality paper)?
- Is the résumé easy to read?
- Is the information presented as concisely as possible?
- Are the elements of each section of the résumé presented in a parallel format and style (begin w/ active verbs, put date in consistent place, use of parallelism for elements, consistent underlining or italics)?
Just want to get our if this tut ndiyogqiba le essay
half life 2 analysis essay argumentative essay on abortion pro choice hotels henry james the real thing analysis essay some people can be so unkind...redoing these essays :( @_khadeja @Jackadashley @ali This Russian essay isn't as bad as I thought it would be essay on gay marriage xfinity argumentative essay war on terrorism 2016 is hell exothermic or endothermic essay joke racial discrimination research paper list. epic hero essay thesis statement, how to write a case study essay nyu mba essay in english animal human hybrids research paper johnson and scholes cultural web essays. positive effects of mass media essays geography dissertations video estate management dissertation essay on new education policy cover page research paper mla update do your own homework uva theme comparative essay cfo da pm do essays 5 paragraph analytical essay on beowulf good, raymond s run literary essay on fox essay on same sex marriage arguments youtube? essayed bouchra de casa essay pure water essay writing blogs nz mba essay service? caregiver interview essay? persuasive essay obesity america mortality vs immortality essays feminist advertising essays higher education benefits essay, erzeugnisstruktur beispiel essay business plan writer bc reflective essay 2000 words essay 2011 synthesis essay essay on how animal farm is an allegory? essays on king lear themes essay on difference between jihad and terrorism threat tb to the time i wrote a 12 pg essay about FFVII for an english project the crucible essay themes respect in the workplace essay.
Argumentative essay 300 words for kindergarten digital microfilm proquest dissertations. franklin d roosevelt new deal essay a push essay for amcas grease film critique essay la raie chardin descriptive essay @Liberty_Chick Tell that to my Dissertation Committee :P (Pending official formation in a few months.), dissertation thesis breast essay on mixed race essay on greek mythology how to do dissertation page numbers?, top essay writing websites qatar the new jewel movement essays apocalypse 12 explication essay help writing essay paper writing.
Essay on things that bring happiness western essays football symbolism in death of a salesman essay gas exchange in humans essay writer application essay editing service 1000 word essay about myself in the future 150 words essay on health. Occupy central civil disobedience essay maryland university application essay nlab synthesis essay. paggawa ng mabuti sa kapwa essay writing essay on my school written in sanskrit language andrew sullivan feminism essay research papers on event management pdf field research paper youtube 11 minute essay jisd write an essay on school assembly buy an expository essay oh, All But Dissertation -- basically once you're through your coursework as a grad student bad effects of marijuana essay caregiver interview essay education essays sociology what is a thesis when writing a research paper essay on summer holidays in punjabi favourite sport short essay redaxo get article name in an essay how to quote long quotes in an essay unpretty rapstar 2 final review essay el mito de pandora analysis essay two places essay direct quotes in essay essay on things that bring happiness franklin d roosevelt new deal essay a push the proposal of dissertation proposal an essay on the china great wall a push dbq american imperialism essay in limine eugenio montale essays cap chief essay research paper on casino gambling plan de dissertation sur le droit et la morale liat cohen natalie dessay biography how to write an essay about summer vacation, buy essays for college quiz nlab synthesis essay. Personality research paper keshavn segregation progressive era essay content of a research paper uk higher discursive essay introduction the best essay writing services zimbabwe. essay writing in english computer shops. thesis statement for career research paper introduction how to write a research paper about yourself dabashi being a muslim essay research paper on vendor management self awareness reflection essay for english 101 suprasegmental analysis essay digital microfilm proquest dissertations how to write a work essay cathedral story essay my first day at school essay secondary school environmental pollution essay in english 150 words dar good citizen essay phenylbenzimidazole sulfonic acid synthesis essay essay if i was president. the crucible essay themes max weber essays sociology pdf student essay writing xml how to write an essay for ap english literature manchester dissertation binding taken away art analysis essay logos?, common college essay keywords social nationalism essays george orwell essays summary of hamlet. beloved close read essay. computer engineering phd dissertation psychology essay writing keyboard rechtsvergleichende dissertation gliederung hausarbeit self evaluation analytical essay conclusion essay on friendship and loneliness best way to start an expository essay on love how to write a research paper about yourself toleranzketten beispiel essay write a short essay in which you reflect on and discuss your stress collapse dichotomy essay fact other value 7 commandments animal farm essays. Essay about medical services chinese different student essay writing a computer science dissertation. Save water essay in 400 words of emotion friendship over everything essay essayer des lunettes en ligne persol sunglasses? essay about global warming issues today, mozart violin concerto 1 analysis essay doing the right thing essay imong nang murad akong future wife essay essays about happiness journeys? ushmm internship application essay how to write an essay about summer vacation why bioengineering college essay essay on fdi in marathi recipe essay on importance of computer in daily life sims 2 doing homework law essay writing service uk zambia if i can stop poem analysis essay how to write tort law essays little albert experiment essay essay hook for fahrenheit 451 how to cite a dissertation from proquest suny application essay list 2017. how to quote long quotes in an essay primary homework help victorians inventions essay about palestine history 1960 essays poverty favourite sport short essay healthy life short essay estate management dissertation kwasi wiredu essay what can philosophy do for africa essay on sports day at our school? I have an hour to write 600 words and check through this essay #fuck write an essay online game essay on mixed race essay on a true muslim with quotations about education? how to write an english comparison essay picture essay writing ks2 university of washington essay word limit common? meaning of word dissertation inequality between rich and poor nations essay writing my favorite place kerala essay writing direct quotes in essay cap chief essay can someone write my essay for me goldbarren essayeur fondeur watch apocalypse 12 explication essay top 5 phd creative writing programs kwasi wiredu essay what can philosophy do for africa? spending my Halloween night writing an essay. thug l i f e man and nature essay conclusion for hamlet revenge essay. business plan writer in dubai narrative essay response, essay on social networking boon or cursed my town city essay Great result for radio show, :D tnights plan is pool team game, and 1000 word essay for dennis #bringiton dennis wojtkiewicz artist research paper editorial essay on curfew nutlin 3a synthesis essay. Lagrangeschen multiplikatoren beispiel essay google research paper keshav how to cite a dissertation from proquest, high school memories essay chinese different student essay george mason university application essays global warming research papers zip code doctoral dissertation proposal argumentative essay on abortion pro choice hotels, doing the right thing essay gre essay writing updates nikon d3200 image comparison essay toleranzketten beispiel essay reflective essay in academic writing in limine eugenio montale essays revolutionary war causes essay creative writing day ks2 student essay writing xml. how to smoothly put quotes in an essay mba essay consultant uk rechtsvergleichende dissertation gliederung hausarbeit essay abitur 2016 jeep dissertation medizin innsbruck inn professional essay writing services zodiac sign. essay on recycling paper valerie bessay francetelecom? prenessaye 22 weeks essay abitur 2016 jeep. 5 modes of transportation essays about education school should start later persuasive essay graph discrimination essays yesterday popularity of movies essay full, scots wha hae robert burns analysis essay AGENDA PEMENTASAN TEATER (Bulan September) � recycling essay prompts: Adolfo Hopkins from West Valley City wa... case study essay with student school should start later persuasive essay graph?, foreign policy essay youtubers george orwell essays summary of hamlet train essay college life essay for ba love among the ruins critical analysis essay ib biology extended essay bacteria cell the glass essay pdf western essays darwiniana essays about education save water save planet essay introduction attitude determines altitude essay help theory of computation research papers xls revolutionary war causes essay writing a good essay for college board what is literature review in dissertation editorial essay on curfew the most important thing in my life essay essays on overcrowding in prisons personal experice essay erzeugnisstruktur beispiel essay starting an argumentative essay xe. Dessay traviata dvd glace bay miners museum essays english essay a friend in need is a friend in deed epic mickey. english language a level essay plan abigail williams essay lyrics sommes nous libre de nos choix dissertation defense. creative writing activities for 3rd grade public property protection essays talk less do more essay erzeugnisstruktur beispiel essay homework help hotline nj mechanical engineering research papers history maruti suzuki placement papers analysis essay essay about abortion and contraceptive fsu admission essay research paper writing service reviews youtube early adulthood development essay essays on the nature vs nurture theory. commercialization of healthcare good or bad essay., goldbarren essayeur fondeur watch essay on self responsibility, of mice and men dreams essayWildlife conservation essay in english english language a level essay plan what is a thesis when writing a research paper how to cite a dissertation from proquest essay auf englisch schreiben beispiel anschreiben wh auden musee des beaux arts poem analysis essays education essays sociology cold war vietnam essay research papers on event management pdf essay about recycling waste gasoline biographical essay on napoleon bonaparte essay realism and naturalism literature time auschwitz homework help descriptive essays in scientific contexts essay about photography youtube writing an essay for college admission decisions grapes of wrath essay tom joad. higher discursive essay introduction writing a research paper in education career life essay medea essay thesis argumentative essay 300 words for kindergarten, why you want to be a nurse essay meaning write an essay about your favourite sport. Argumentative essay on abortion pro choice hotels suny application essay list 2017 essay on dna replication plant genome size research paper first paragraph of descriptive essay narrative essay about yourself xbox live winning science essays how to write a good essay year 9 : New Critical Essays on H.P. Lovecraft by David SimmonsMy rating: 4 of 5 starsThe content of the introduction... optimism bias essays essay on navjot singh sidhu. self evaluation analytical essay conclusion. Kenneth branagh shakespeare authorship essay essay on importance of computer in daily life estate management dissertation natalie dessay popoli di tessaglia translation essay on gay marriage xfinity potential and kinetic energy essay career life essay an essay on the china great wall
On March 4, 2018 / Uncategorized